Skip to main content

No TRO on Trillanes’ rebellion case with Makati RTC – CA

The Court of Appeals (CA) did not issue a temporary restraining order (TRO) that would stop the proceedings in the revived rebellion case against Sen. Antonio Trillanes IV in connection with the 2007 Manila Peninsula Hotel siege in Makati City.
Senator Antonio Trillanes IV (Czar Dancel / MANILA BULLETIN)
Senator Antonio Trillanes IV
(Czar Dancel / MANILA BULLETIN)
In a three-page resolution written by Associate Justice Apolinario D. Bruselas Jr., the CA said that even the Supreme Court (SC) did not issue any ancillary relief to Trillanes when he elevated the nullification of his amnesty through President Duterte’s Proclamation No. 572.
It noted that the SC left to the trial courts the resolution of the factual issues on Trillanes’ petition.
The CA also noted that while Branch 150 of the Makati City regional trial court (RTC) had issued a hold departure order and a warrant of arrest against Trillanes on the rebellion case, the senator has posted bail and is out on provisional liberty.
“Given the foregoing state of facts, the ancillary remedies applied for may not be granted at this time without running afoul with the principle that provisional reliefs may not be granted in advance of the main action where the provisional relief is the very remedy prayed for in the complaint or petition,” the CA said.
“We may not temporarily restrain or preliminarily enjoin the prosecution of the criminal action for rebellion at this stage because to do so would be to grant the principal prayer for certiorari, prohibition and/or injunction without the benefit of a hearing,” it also said.
“Accordingly, the application for a temporary restraining order (TRO) or a writ of preliminary prohibitory injunction is denied at this time,” the CA ruled.
It ordered the Makati City prosecutor’s office and the Department of Justice (DOJ) to comment on Trillanes’ petition in 10 days from receipt of the resolution dated March 18, 2019. Trillanes was given five days to reply to the comment “if he be so minded.”
Earlier, Judge Elmo Alameda of Makati City RTC Branch 150 had denied Trillanes’ motion to reconsider the reinstatement of his rebellion case. The denial prompted Trillanes to elevate the case before the CA.
Judge Alameda stood pat on his findings in September last year that Trillanes failed to prove his compliance with the minimum requirement when he applied for amnesty during the previous administration.
The six-page order issued by Judge Alameda stated:
“Unfortunately, Sen. Trillanes failed to prove that the original of the alleged application form exists. Sen. Trillanes even failed to explain his failure to locate or find the copy thereof.
“Since the existence of the fact of his admission of guilty of the crime’ he committed, the substitutionary evidence presented by Sen. Trillanes is considered hearsay evidence and cannot be admitted as evidence to prove compliance with the minimum requirement set forth in Proclamation No. 75 (Amnesty Grant).”
Alameda also reiterated that “Sen. Trillanes was not able to prove through testimonial and documentary evidence that he filed his application for amnesty nor expressly admitted his guilty in the application form for the crime he committed during the Manila Peninsula incident which are the minimum requirement set forth under Proclamation No. 75.”
On Trillanes’ coup d’etat case in connection with the 2003 Oakwood mutiny, Judge Andres Soriano of Makati City RTC Branch 148 had denied the DOJ’s plea to revive the case with a ruling that the case had already been dismissed and terminated.
But Judge Soriano upheld the constitutionality of Proclamation No. 572 which voided Trillanes’ amnesty on both the coup d’etat and rebellion cases.
Soriano’s ruling was challenged by the DOJ before the CA.
Last February, the CA — in a resolution issued by Associate Justices Sesinando E. Villon, Edwin D. Sorongon and Germano Francisco D. Legaspi – required Trillanes to comment on the DOJ petition.
The DOJ, through Solicitor General Jose C. Calida, sought the reversal of Soriano’s ruling.
Calida said the trial court erred “in holding that the judgment already attained finality and was, therefore immutable” and also “in admitting and giving credence to the Trillanes’ secondary evidence,” including the photo of his alleged acceptance of the amnesty.
“The respondent judge could not have determined that Trillanes filed his amnesty application and admitted his guilt because the J1-AFP, the DND Records Division, the Office of the Undersecretary for Defense Affairs, and the trial court have no copies of the amnesty application,” he said.
Calida pointed out that in the absence of the original copy of Trillanes’ amnesty application form, his amnesty cannot be considered valid because “it cannot be conclusively said that Trillanes expressly admitted that he committed the crimes of rebellion and coup d’etat for his active involvement and participation in Oakwood mutiny and Manila Peninsula Siege.”
Source and Original Article from: >>> Manila Bulletin

Comments

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Popular posts from this blog

A Scandalous Mess That Maria Ressa Of Rappler Left In ABS-CBN Shocks The Netizens

Maria Ressa of Rappler, photo from  ABS-CBN News Maria Ressa of Rappler is widely known for her fierce way of defending what she believes in. Nowadays, she is often seen as the straight talker CEO and owner of Rappler. But what some people do not know, or may have forgotten, is that she was once the Senior Vice President of ABS-CBN. A guy who used to work in ANC revealed what a mess Maria Ressa left at ABS-CBN. Woman of substance In 2005, ABS-CBN added Maria Ressa to their roster of their board as a News Consultant. Because of her American Standard of journalism, she was chosen to help overhaul ABS-CBN News. While she was there, it has not been quiet. She actually had two controversies that stuck to her. First, she fired 35 employees, which were supposedly just putting weight in the company. The second is the most scandalous, she had cheated on her long term partner with ABS-CBN Producer Lilibeth Frondoso. Or not All admirations from the employees th

TP reveals documents of alleged Trillanes relatives who got 2015 MRT-3 P7.28M deal without proper bidding

combined photo of Thinking Pinoy or also known as blogger Rey Joseph “RJ” Nieto and Senator Antonio Trillanes (from CNN) Manila, Philippines - Another issue has been haunting the embattled Senator Antonio Trillanes IV after Thinking Pinoy (TP) blog revealed names of alleged Trillanes’ relatives linked to the anomalous MRT-3 deals. Aside from dropping names, Thinking Pinoy or also known as blogger Rey Joseph “RJ” Nieto gathered documents to support his claim. Further, he also urged the Ombudsman to check if the contract awarded to the said firm complied to  Government Procurement Reform Act. In his Facebook post, Thinking Pinoy cited that former Aquino administration, in 2015 allegedly awarded without public bidding a P7.28-million MRT-3 communications maintenance contract to Trilink Technologies, a firm being managed by Senator Trillanes’ relative. Below is the complete post from Thinking Pinoy that has gone viral as of this writing: DOCS SHOW TRILLANE

DOJ summons suspects in the killing of former Biliran solon’s aide

Photo from Department of Justice Twenty-three police officers have been summoned to the Department of Justice (DOJ) to face the murder complaints against them concerning the killing of the aide of former Biliran Representative Glenn Chong and a female companion. “Subpoenas have been issued to the respondents,” said Senior Assistant State Prosecutor Alexander Suarez, who has been assigned to handle the case. Suarez cited that the respondents were directed to appear at the start of the preliminary investigation this Thursday and submit counter-affidavits in response to the allegations against them. “Those who failed to file counter-affidavits will be given another chance,” he assured. Last May 17, the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) filed before the Department of Justice (DOJ) criminal complaints concerning the December killing of Chong’s aide, Richard Santillan and his female companion Gessamyn Casing last in Barangay San Andres in Cainta, Rizal. In its comp